Monday, January 6, 2014

Church Wars: The Battle of Catholicism and Protestantism in England


        The 17th century was a tumultuous time for England, as for the rest of Europe. Political squabbles, economic depravity, and social strife were rampant, made all the worse by the ongoing battle for power between the Roman Catholic church and the fledgling Protestant sects. Or was it the other way around? Did the clash between the Protestants and Catholics fuel the already dilapidated socioeconomic climate, or was the religious row the catalyst of the whole situation?


        England's Glorious Revolution ended the absolute monarchy in place, and instead replaced it with a "constitutional monarchy", handing over much of the control of England to Parliament. Driven by the fear of what a Catholic monarch may attempt, James II was cast out, being replaced by his Protestant daughter Mary and her husband, William of Orange. Despite the Revolution being relatively bloodless, with only Scotland and Ireland putting up resistance, it's impact on British society was considerable, gradually bringing long lasting changes. Even after William and Mary died with no heir, Parliament was able to place Anne – another of James II's Protestant daughters – on the throne. But this fear of a resurgence of "popery" was not held by Parliament alone: it was widespread throughout the kingdom. This fear went beyond hatred and ventured into the realm of paranoia, as the majority of the people of England, many of whom were Protestant since birth, believed that Catholics were systematically plotting the downfall of both the Anglican Church and English state. This intricate conspiracy theory claimed that the Pope would then establish Catholic-led tyranny, not unlike the absolute monarchy in France, reducing England to a mere puppet state. It is interesting to note, however, that this conspiracy theory was given some measure of credibility, due to the fact that there actually was some real Catholic subterfuge, the most notable of which was Guy Fawkes' 1605 Gunpowder Plot. (Vallance, 2011)

         Thus, despite James' Catholic descendents attempting to stir a rebellion that would carry them out of exile in France and back to the English throne, it would never happen, as public support was suppressed by the paranoia about Catholics. In fact, the people and Parliament thought it better to give the crown to the Germans than to the French. That is when King George I entered the scene: a Stuart by blood, German by culture, and ruler of Hanover, but the next Protestant with claim to the English Crown. However, neither George I or his son, George II, were fluent in English, understood or cared much about England, and they never presided over the Cabinet meetings. (Damerow, 2011) Because of this, Sir Robert Walpole, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, became the first Prime Minister, holding this position from 1721 to 1742. Answering both to the king and to a majority in the House of Commons, Walpole became the de facto leader of the nation, and the Crown began its descent into being a mere figurehead; however, when Sir Robert's parliamentary majority was lost, he proceeded to resign from his post, despite still having the support of the king. By doing so, he provided a model for all Prime Ministers after him, and set a precedent for all future leaders of this fundamentally different England. (Damerow, 2011)
 
          During all of this, mass exploration was going on as well. The ever present threat of France was multiplied when they sent Jacques Cartier to the New World, followed by René-Robert-Cavelier, Sieur de La Salle, among others. To the English mind, the Catholic French could not go unopposed, so in 1585, the English established an ultimately unsuccessful settlement on Roanoke Island. However, they made more attempts shortly thereafter, with settlements at Jamestown and Plymouth. Finally, in March of 1630, roughly 900 Puritans sailed to the New World and established the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Other colonies were rapidly founded in succession: Maryland, Connecticut, New Hampshire, and Pennsylvania. (Kreis, 2009) These colonies were well established, with governments approved and placed by the Crown when the Glorious Revolution rattled the home country. One of the governors in Colonies was a man by the name of Sir Edmund Andros, a heavily pro-Anglican authoritarian man, and one despised by most of the largely Puritan population. Tensions were high in the colonies, between Indian raids and Andros' own harsh policies and crackdowns, when word of the Glorious Revolution spread to America. (Alchin, 2012) In April of 1698, the Boston colonists revolted against the tyranny of Andros, descending on the city and arresting government officials and other Anglicans. Former colonial governor Simon Bradstreet led what the British called a "mob", but was closer to an organized militia, to the steps of Fort Mary, where Andros had barricaded himself. Bradstreet served up the terms of surrender, which Andros refused, and instead attempted to flee to the Rose, the last of the Royal Navy presence near Boston at the time. However, the boat sent from the Rose was intercepted by militia, and Andros was forced back to negotiations. He was taken into captivity, and meanwhile, in New York, Lieutenant Governor Francis Nicholson was toppled by Jacob Leisler's New York militia, something that has come to be called Leisler's Rebellion. New York would be governed by Leisler until 1691, when he was arrested and put to death by an army led by the provincial governor, newly-appointed by the Crown. Andros was ultimately permitted to leave to England, but by then, his Dominion of New England had practically come to an end, and the colonies making up the Dominion reverting back to their prior styles of government. As Linda Alchin wrote that the "rebellion the American colonies, which although were short lived, can be seen as precursors to the American Revolution." (2012)

         Overall, the Glorious Revolution was a nearly bloodless insurrection that this author would assert was caused by the tensions between Protestants and Catholics. It was supplemented by the socioeconomic and political strife rampant at the time, and was felt all throughout the farthest reaches of the fledgling empire. The impact in the American Colonies was both a symbol and a forerunner of what was to come, but staved off the inevitable revolution for 88 more years.

References
Alchin, L. (2012, March 1). Land of the Brave: Glorious Revolution of 1688. Retrieved from http://www.landofthebrave.info/glorious-revolution.htm
Damerow, H. (2011, July 12). Glorious Revolution. Retrieved from http://faculty.ucc.edu/egh-damerow/glorious_revolution.htm
Kreis, S. (2009, August 4). Lecture 6: Europe in the Age of Religious Wars, 1560-1715. Retrieved from http://www.historyguide.org/earlymod/lecture6c.html
Vallance, E. (2011, February 17). BBC - History - British History in depth: The Glorious Revolution. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/civil_war_revolution/glorious_revolution_01.shtml

No comments:

Post a Comment